|Table of Contents|

Research Progress of Seismic Collapse Resistance of Reinforced Concrete Structures Based on Damage Criteria(PDF)

《建筑科学与工程学报》[ISSN:1673-2049/CN:61-1442/TU]

Issue:
2010年02期
Page:
51-60
Research Field:
Publishing date:
2010-06-20

Info

Title:
Research Progress of Seismic Collapse Resistance of Reinforced Concrete Structures Based on Damage Criteria
Author(s):
PAN Yuan;  LIU Bo-quan;  XING Guo-hua;  WU Tao
School of Civil Engineering, Chang'an University, Xi'an 710061, Shaanxi, China
Keywords:
reinforced concrete;  frame structure;  damage criterion;  displacement ductility;  collapse;  cumulative damage identification
PACS:
TU375.4
DOI:
-
Abstract:
In order to further study the seismic collapse resistance of reinforced concrete structures, a summary of existing experimental investigation and theoretical analysis of seismic collapse resistance of building structures at home and abroad was presented. The state-of-the-art of studies on damage criterion of earthquake resistant structures for the collapse analysis was analyzed emphatically. Based on the summary of previous research, the existing problems of seismic collapse resistance of reinforced concrete frame structures based on damage criteria were addressed and pointed out for further study. That collapse criteria and damage assessment indexes of reinforced concrete frame structures should be determined based on member damage criteria were suggested. The research results can serve as a theoretical basis for further calculation analysis and quantitative design on seismic collapse resistance of reinforced concrete structures.

References:

[1] 清华大学、西南交通大学、北京交通大学土木工程结构专家组.汶川地震建筑震害分析[J].建筑结构学报,2008,29(4):1-9. Civil and Structural Groups of Tsinghua University,Southwest Jiaotong University and Beijing Jiaotong University.Analysis on Seismic Damage of Buildings in the Wenchuan Earthquake[J].Journal of Building Structures,2008,29(4):1-9.
[2]王亚勇.汶川地震建筑震害启示——三水准设防和抗震设计基本要求[J].建筑结构学报,2008,29(4):26-33. WANG Ya-yong.Lessons Learnt from Building Damages in the Wenchuan Earthquake-Three Earthquake Performance Objectives and Basic Requirements for Seismic Design of Buildings[J].Journal of Building Structures,2008,29(4):26-33.
[3]GB 50011—2001,建筑抗震设计规范[S]. GB 50011—2001,Code for Seismic Design of Buildings[S].
[4]ACI 318-08,Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete(ACI 318-08)and Commentary[S].
[5]GSA 2003,Progressive Collapse Analysis and Design Guidelines for New Federal Office Buildings and Major Modernization Projects[S].
[6]UFC 4-010-01,Design of Building to Resist Progressive Collapse[S].
[7]ASCE/SEI 7-05,Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures[S].
[8]BS 6399-1:1996,Loading for Buildings.Part 1: Code of Practice for Dead and Imposed Loads[S].
[9]ICC 2005,International Building Code[S].
[10]CCBFC 1995,National Building Code of Canada[S].
[11]DEIERLEIN G G,LIEL A B,HASELTON C B,et al.ATC 63 Methodology for Evaluating Seismic Collapse Safety of Archetype Buildings[C/CD]//ANDERSON D,VENTURA C,HARVEY D,et al.Structural Congress 2008:Crossing Borders.Vancouver:ASCE,2008:1-10.
[12]刘伯权,赖 明,白绍良.地震作用下剪切型结构的可靠性分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,1996,16(1):39-48. LIU Bo-quan,LAI Ming,BAI Shao-liang.Reliability Analysis of Shear Type Structures Subjected to Earthquake[J].Earthquake Engineering and En-gineering Vibration,1996,16(1):39-48.
[13]KIM H S,KIM J,AN D W.Development of Integrated System for Progressive Collapse Analysis of Building Structures Considering Dynamic Effects[J].Advances in Engineering Software,2009,40(1):1-8.
[14]ELLINGWOOD B R.Mitigating Risk from Abnormal Loads and Progressive Collapse[J].Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities,2006,20(4):315-323.
[15]BAKER J F.Plasticity as a Factor in the Design of War-time Structures[R].London:Institution of Civil Engineers,1948:30-53.
[16]BAKER J F,LEAD W E,LAX P.The Design of Framed Buildings Against High-explosive Bombs[R].London:Institution of Civil Engineers,1948:80-113.
[17]PEARSON C,DELATTE N.Ronan Point Apartment Tower Collapse and Its Effect on Building Codes[J].Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities,2005,19(2):172-177.
[18]KAEWKULCHAI G,WILLIAMSON E B.Beam Elem-ent Formulation and Solution Procedure for Dynamic Progressive Collapse Analysis[J].Computers & Structures,2004,82(7/8):639-651.
[19]SOZEN M A,SRMLAKAR P F,CORLEY W G.The Oklahoma City Bombing:Structure and Mechanisms of the Murrah Building[J].Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities,1998,12(3):120-136.
[20]陆新征,江见鲸.世界贸易中心飞机撞击后倒塌过程的仿真分析[J].土木工程学报,2001,34(6):8-10. LU Xin-zheng,JIANG Jian-jing.Dynamic Finite Elem-ent Simulation for the Collapse of World Trade Center[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,2001,34(6):8-10.
[21]TAYLOR D.Progressive Collapse[J].Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering,1975,2(4):517-529.
[22]BREEN J E,SIESS C P.Progressive Collapse-Symposium Summary[J].ACI Structural Journal,1979,76(9):997-1004.
[23]ELLINGWOOD B R,LEYENDECKER E V.Ap-proaches for Design Against Progressive Collapse[J].Journal of the Structural Division,1978,104(3):413-423.
[24]GROSS J L,MCGUIRE W.Progressive Collapse Resistant Design[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,1983,109(1):1-15.
[25]WOOD S L,STARK R,GREER S A.Collapse of Eight-story RC Building During 1985 Chile Earthquake[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,1991,117(2):600-619.
[26]刘伯权,赖 明,杨 红.多层建筑考虑低周疲劳特性的地震倒塌反应分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,1994,14(2):86-93. LIU Bo-quan,LAI Ming,YANG Hong.Analysis of Collapse Earthquake Responses of Multi-story Buildings Taking Account of Structural Low-cycle Fatigue Character[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,1994,14(2):86-93.
[27]CORLEY W G,MLAKAR P F,SOZEN M A,et al.The Oklahoma City Bombing:Summary and Recommendations for Multihazard Mitigation[J].Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities,1998,12(3):100-112.
[28]魏 琏,戴国莹.唐山地震作用下一座三层钢筋混凝土框架结构倒塌的分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,1981,1(1):25-33. WEI Lian,DAI Guo-ying.A Study on the Collapse of a Three-storey Reinforced Concrete Framed Structure in a Factory During the Tangshan Earthquakes[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,1981,1(1):25-33.
[29]王志浩,苗启松,陈肇元.冲击波作用下剪力墙房屋的倒塌试验研究[J].建筑结构学报,1993,14(1):26-34. WANG Zhi-hao,MIAO Qi-song,CHEN Zhao-yuan.Experimental Study on Collapse Process of Shear Wall Building Under Blast Loading[J].Journal of Building Structures,1993,14(1):26-34.
[30]VIAN D,BRUNEAU M.Tests to Structural Collapse of Single Degree of Freedom Frames Subjected to Earthquake Excitations[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,2003,129(12):1676-1685.
[31]ELWOOD K J.Shake Table Tests and Analytical Studies on the Gravity Load Collapse of Reinforced Concrete Frames[D].Berkeley:University of California,2002.
[32]ELWOOD K J,MOEHLE J P.Drift Capacity of Re-inforced Concrete Columns with Light Transverse Reinforcement[J].Earthquake Spectra,2005,21(1):71-89.
[33]NAKASHIMA M,MATSUMIYA T,SUITA K,et al.Test on Full-scale Three-storey Steel Moment Frame and Assessment of Ability of Numerical Simulation to Trace Cyclic Inelastic Behaviour[J].Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics,2005,35(1):3-19.
[34]KASAI K,OOKI Y,MOTOYUI S,et al.E-defense Tests on Full-scale Steel Buildings:Part 1 — Experiments Using Dampers and Isolators[C]//ASCE.Structural Engineering Research Frontiers 2007.Long Beach:ASCE,2007:1-12.
[35]SUITA K,YAMADA S,TADA M,et al.Results of Recent E-defense Tests on Full-scale Steel Buildings:Part 1 — Collapse Experiments on 4-story Moment Frames[C/CD]//ANDERSON D,VENTURA C,HARVEY D,et al.Structural Congress 2008:Crossing Borders.Vancouver:ASCE,2008:1-10.
[36]YAVARI S,ELWOOD K J,LIN S H,et al.Experimental Study on Dynamic Behavior of Multi-story Reinforced Concrete Frames with Non-seismic Detailing[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of the 2009 ATC & SEI Conference on Improving the Seismic Performance of Existing Buildings and Other Structures.San Francisco:ASCE,2009:489-499.
[37]YI W J,HE Q F,XIAO Y,et al.Experimental Study on Progressive Collapse-resistant Behavior of Re-inforced Concrete Frame Structures[J].ACI Structural Journal,2008,105(4):433-439.
[38]SASANI M,BAZAN M,SAGIROGLU S.Experimental and Analytical Progressive Collapse Evaluation of Actual Reinforced Concrete Structure[J].ACI Structural Journal,2007,104(6):731-739.
[39]AKINCI N O.An Investigation on Seismic Resistance of Reinforced Concrete Industrial Chimneys[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of the 2009 ATC & SEI Conference on Improving the Seismic Performance of Existing Buildings and Other Structures.San Francisco:ASCE,2009:964-971.
[40]SASANI M,SAGIROGLU S.Progressive Collapse Resistance of Hotel San Diego[J].Journal of Structural Engineering,2008,134(3):478-488.
[41]BANGASH T,MUNJIZA A.A Computationally Efficient Beam Element for FEM/DEM Simulations of Structural Failure and Collapse[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Discrete Element Methods.New Mexico:ASCE,2002:133-137.
[42]金伟良,方 韬.钢筋混凝土框架结构破坏性能的离散单元法模拟[J].工程力学,2005,22(4):67-73. JIN Wei-liang,FANG Tao.Numerical Simulation of Failure Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Frame Structures by Discrete Element Method[J].Engineering Mechanics,2005,22(4):67-73.
[43]SCOTT M H,FENVES G L.Krylov Subspace Accelerated Newton Algorithm Application to Dynamic Progressive Collapse Simulation of Frames[J].Journal of Structural Engineering,2010,136(5):473-480.
[44]吕大刚,于晓辉,王光远.基于单地震动记录IDA方法的结构倒塌分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,2009,29(6):33-39. LU Da-gang,YU Xiao-hui,WANG Guang-yuan.Structural Collapse Analysis Based on Single-record IDA Method[J].Journal of Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,2009,29(6):33-39.
[45]SU Y P,QI J R,LIU Y.Finite Element Simulation on Progressive Collapse Resistance of Reinforced-concrete Frame[C]//ASCE.Proceeding of the Eleventh Biennial ASCE Aerospace Division International Conference on Engineering,Science,Construction,and Operation in Challenging Environments.Long Beach:ASCE,2008:1-7.
[46]PUJOL S,SMITH-PARDO J P.A New Perspective on the Effects of Abrupt Column Removal[J].Engin-eering Structures,2009,31(4):869-874.
[47]MOHAMED O A.Assessment of Progressive Collapse Potential in Corner Floor Panels of Reinforced Concrete Buildings[J].Engineering Structures,2009,31(3):749-757.
[48]TSAI M H,LIN B H.Investigation of Progressive Collapse Resistance and Inelastic Response for an Earthquake-resistant RC Building Subjected to Column Failure[J].Engineering Structures,2008,30(12):3619-3628.
[49]KWASNIEWSKI L.Nonlinear Dynamic Simulations of Progressive Collapse for a Multistory Building[J].Engineering Structures,2010,32(5):1223-1235.
[50]LEE C H,KIM S,HAN K H,et al.Simplified Nonlinear Progressive Collapse Analysis of Welded Steel Moment Frames[J].Journal of Constructional Steel Research,2009,65(5):1130-1137.
[51]唐曹明,徐培福,徐自国,等.钢筋混凝土框架结构楼层刚度比限制方法研究[J].土木工程学报,2009,42(12):128-134. TANG Cao-ming,XU Pei-fu,XU Zi-guo,et al.A Study of the Method for Limiting the Story Stiffness Ratio of RC Frame Structures[J].China Civil En-gineering Journal,2009,42(12):128-134.
[52]师燕超,李忠献,郝 洪.爆炸荷载作用下钢筋混凝土框架结构的连续倒塌分析[J].解放军理工大学学报:自然科学版,2007,8(6):652-658. SHI Yan-chao,LI Zhong-xian,HAO Hong.Numerical Analysis of Progressive Collapse of Reinforced Concrete Frame Under Blast Loading[J].Journal of PLA University of Science and Technology:Natural Science Edition,2007,8(6):652-658.
[53]陆新征,李 易,叶列平,等.钢筋混凝土框架结构抗连续倒塌设计方法的研究[J].工程力学,2008,25(增2):150-157. LU Xin-zheng,LI Yi,YE Lie-ping,et al.Study on Design Method to Resist Progressive Collapse for Re-inforced Concrete Frames[J].Engineering Mechanics,2008,25(S2):150-157.
[54]宣 纲,顾祥林,吕西林.强震作用下混凝土框架结构倒塌过程的数值分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,2003,23(6):24-30. XUAN Gang,GU Xiang-lin,LU Xi-lin.Numerical Analysis of Collapse Process for RC Frame Structures Subjected to Strong Earthquakes[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,2003,23(6):24-30.
[55]IRTEM E,TURKER K,HASGUL U.Causes of Collapse and Damage to Low-rise RC Buildings in Recent Turkish Earthquakes[J].Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities,2007,21(5):351-360.
[56]苏幼坡,张玉敏,王绍杰,等.从汶川地震看提高建筑结构抗倒塌能力的必要性和可行性[J].土木工程学报,2009,42(5):25-32. SU You-po,ZHANG Yu-min,WANG Shao-jie,et al.The Necessity and Feasibility of Enhancing Seismic Design of Structures Based on the Wenchuan Earthquake[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,2009,42(5):25-32.
[57]张富文,吕西林.框架结构不同倒塌模式的数值模拟与分析[J].建筑结构学报,2009,30(5):119-125. ZHANG Fu-wen,LU Xi-lin.Numerical Simulation and Analysis of Different Collapse Patterns for RC Frame Structure[J].Journal of Building Structures,2009,30(5):119-125.
[58]林旭川,潘 鹏,叶列平,等.汶川地震中典型RC框架结构的震害仿真与分析[J].土木工程学报,2009,42(5):13-20. LIN Xu-chuan,PAN Peng,YE Lie-ping,et al.Analysis of the Damage Mechanism of a Typical RC Frame in Wenchuan Earthquake[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,2009,42(5):13-20.
[59]叶列平,陆新征,赵世春,等.框架结构抗地震倒塌能力的研究——汶川地震极震区几个框架结构震害案例分析[J].建筑结构学报,2009,30(6):67-76. YE Lie-ping,LU Xin-zheng,ZHAO Shi-chun,et al.Seismic Collapse Resistance of RC Frame Structures-Case Studies on Seismic Damages of Several RC Frame Structures Under Extreme Ground Motion in Wenchuan Earthquake[J].Journal of Building Structures,2009,30(6):67-76.
[60]OTANI S.RC Building Damage Statistics and SDF Response with Design Seismic Forces[J].Earthquake Spectra,1999,15(3):485-501.
[61]刘伯权,白绍良,刘 鸣.抗震结构的等效延性破坏准则及其子结构试验验证[J].地震工程与工程振动,1997,17(3):77-83. LIU Bo-quan,BAI Shao-liang,LIU Ming.Equivalent Ductility Damage Criteria of Earthquake-resistant Structures and Their Verification by Substructure Method[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,1997,17(3):77-83.
[62]甘 泉,黄良璧.钢筋混凝土抗震框架倒塌分析[J].西安建筑科技大学学报:自然科学版,1998,30(1):1-4. GAN Quan,HUANG Liang-bi.Collapse Analysis of Aseismic R.C Frame Structures[J].Journal of Xi'an University of Architecture & Technology:Natural Science Edition,1998,30(1):1-4.
[63]BAO Y H,KUNNATH S K,EL-TAWIL S,et al.Macromodel-based Simulation of Progressive Collapse:RC Frame Structures[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,2008,134(7):1079-1091.
[64]LASKAR A,GU H C,MO Y L,et al.Progressive Collapse of a 2-story Reinforced Concrete Frame[C]//ASCE.Proceeding of the Eleventh Biennial ASCE Aerospace Division International Conference on Engineering,Science,Construction,and Operation in Challenging Environments.Long Beach:ASCE,2008:11-19.
[65]HARTMANN D,BREIDT M,NGUYEN V,et al.Structural Collapse Simulation Under Consideration of Uncertainty-Fundamental Concept and Results[J].Computers & Structures,2008,86(21/22):2064-2078.
[66]GUNAY S,KOROLYK M,MAR D,et al.Infill Walls as a Spine to Enhance the Seismic Performance of Non-ductile Reinforced Concrete Frames[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of the 2009 ATC & SEI Conference on Improving the Seismic Performance of Existing Buildings and Other Structures.San Francisco:ASCE,2009:1093-1104.
[67]SASANI M.Response of a Reinforced Concrete Infilled-frame Structure to Removal of Two Adjacent Columns[J].Engineering Structures,2008,30(9):2478-2491.
[68]MUNSHI J.State-of-the-art vs.State-of-the Practice in Blast and Progressive Collapse Design of Re-inforced Concrete Structures[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of Structures Congress 2004.Nashville:ASCE,2004:1-10.
[69]沈聚敏,周锡元,高小旺,等.抗震工程学[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2000. SHEN Ju-min,ZHOU Xi-yuan,GAO Xiao-wang,et al.Aseismic Engineering[M].Beijing:China Architecture & Building Press,2000.
[70]刘伯权.抗震结构的破坏准则及可靠性分析[M].北京:中国建材工业出版社,1995. LIU Bo-quan.Damage Criteria and Reliability Analysis of Earthquake Resistant Structures[M].Beijing:China Building Material Industrial Publishing House,1995.
[71]刘伯权,白绍良,赖 明.抗震结构的破坏准则评述及探讨[J].重庆建筑工程学院学报,1993,15(4):1-8,21. LIU Bo-quan,BAI Shao-liang,LAI Ming.A Review and Analysis of Failure Criteria for Aseismic Structures[J].Journal of Chongqing Institute of Architecture and Engineering,1993,15(4):1-8,21.
[72]瞿伟廉,李桂青.建筑结构地震破坏机制的探讨[J].工程抗震,1990(3):27-30. QU Wei-lian,LI Gui-qing.Discussion on Failure Criteria for Building Structures[J].Earthquake Resistant Engineering,1990(3):27-30.
[73]NEWMARK N M.An Engineering Approach to Blast Resistant Design[R].New York:American Society of Civil Engineers Transactions,1956:45-65.
[74]KASIRAJ I,YAO J T P.Fatigue Damage in Seismic Structures[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,1969,95(8):1673-1692.
[75]TANG J P,YAO J T P.Expected Fatigue Damage of Seismic Structures[J].Journal of the Structural En-gineering,1972,98(3):695-708.
[76]BANON H,IRVINE H M,BIGGS J M.Seismic Damage in Reinforced Concrete Frames[J].Journal of the Structural Engineering,1981,107(9):1713-1729.
[77]PARK Y J,ANG H S,WEN Y K.Damage-limiting Aseismic Design of Buildings[J].Earthquake Spectra,1987,3(1):1-26.
[78]陈永祁,龚思礼.结构在地震动时延性和累积塑性耗能的双重破坏准则[J].建筑结构学报,1986,7(1):35-48. CHEN Yong-qi,GONG Si-li.Double Control Damage Index of Structural Ductility and Dissipated Energy During Earthquake[J].Journal of Building Structures,1986,7(1):35-48.
[79]刘伯权,徐云中,白绍良.钢筋混凝土柱在等幅对称位移循环加载下的低周疲劳性能[J].重庆建筑大学学报,1996,18(2):34-42. LIU Bo-quan,XU Yun-zhong,BAI Shao-liang.Low-cyclic Fatigue Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Column Subjected to Symmetric Displacement Cycling[J].Journal of Chongqing Jianzhu University,1996,18(2):34-42.
[80]MCCABE S L,HALL W J.Assessment of Seismic Structural Damage[J].Journal of the Structural En-gineering,1989,115(9):2166-2183.
[81]FAJFAR P.A Nonlinear Analysis Method for Performance Based Seismic Design[J].Earthquake Spectra,2000,16(3):573-592.
[82]SADEGHIK,LAMIRAULT J,SIEFFERT J G.Damage Indicator Improvement Applied on R/C Structures Subjected to Cyclic Loading[C]//MOAN T.Proceedings of the Second European Conference on Structural Dynamics.Rotterdam:Balkema A A,1993:129-136.
[83]RAO P S,SARMA B S,LAKSHMANAN N,et al.Damage Model for Reinforced Concrete Elements Under Cyclic Loading[J].ACI Materials Journal,1998,95(6):682-690.
[84]欧进萍,牛荻涛,王光远.多层非线性抗震钢结构的模糊动力可靠性分析与设计[J].地震工程与工程振动,1990,10(4):27-37. OU Jin-ping,NIU Di-tao,WANG Guang-yuan.Fuzzy Dynamical Reliability Analysis and Design of Multi-story Nonlinear Aseismic Steel Structures[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,1990,10(4):27-37.
[85]欧进萍,吴 波.有损伤压弯构件的恢复力试验研究及其应用[J].建筑结构学报,1995,16(6):21-29. OU Jin-ping,WU Bo.Experimental Research on Restoring Force of Damaged Compresson-flexure Members and Its Applications[J].Journal of Building Structures,1995,16(6):21-29.
[86]牛荻涛,任利杰.改进的钢筋混凝土结构双参数地震破坏模型[J].地震工程与工程振动,1996,16(4):44-54. NIU Di-tao,REN Li-jie.A Modified Seismic Damage Model with Double Variables for Reinforced Concrete Structures[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration,1996,16(4):44-54.
[87]王东升,冯启民,王国新.考虑低周疲劳寿命的改进Park-Ang地震损伤模型[J].土木工程学报,2004,37(11):41-49. WANG Dong-sheng,FENG Qi-min,WANG Guo-xin.A Modified Park-Ang Seismic Damage Model Considering Low-cycle Fatigue Life[J].China Civil En-gineering Journal,2004,37(11):41-49.
[88]KAEWKULCHAI G,WILLIAMSON E B.Beam Elem-ent Formulation and Solution Procedure for Dynamic Progressive Collapse Analysis[J].Computers & Structures,2004,82(7/8):639-651.
[89]SARMA B S,SREENATH H G,BHAGAVAN N G,et al.Experimental Studies on In-plane Ductility of Confined Masonry Panels[J].ACI Structural Journal,2003,100(3):330-336.
[90]YAN Z H,AU F T K.Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis of Frames with Plastic Hinges at Arbitrary Locations[J].The Structural Design of Tall and Special Buildings,2009,18(3):313-325.
[91]EL-BAHY A,KUNNATH S K,STONE W C,et al.Cumulative Seismic Damage of Circular Bridge Columns:Benchmark and Low-cycle Fatigue Tests[J].ACI Structural Journal,1999,96(4):633-641.
[92]EL-BAHY A,KUNNATH S K,STONE W C,et al.Cumulative Seismic Damage of Circular Bridge Columns:Variable Amplitude Tests[J].ACI Structural Journal,1999,96(5):711-719.
[93]ZHANG G W,XIAO Y,KUNNATH S.Low-cycle Fatigue Damage of Circular Concrete-filled-tube Columns[J].ACI Structural Journal,2009,106(2):151-159.
[94]COLOMBO A,NEGRO P.A Damage Index of Generalised Applicability[J].Engineering Structures,2005,27(8):1164-1174.
[95]MOHAMMED T,MOSALAM K M.Towards Modeling Progressive Collapse in Reinforced Concrete Buildings[C]//ASCE.Proceedings of Sessions of the 2007 Structures Congress.Long Beach:ASCE,2007:1-6.

Memo

Memo:
-
Last Update: 2010-06-20